Skip to main content
12.03.2025College Men
Belmont Abbey vs Walsh 2025.
Belmont Abbey is on a roll.
Author: Alex Goff

Did St. Bonaventure put it all together perfectly or did Brown lose the plot?

Maybe it was a bit of both. As the NCR Men’s D1 semifinals loom talk is still about how the defending champion Brown side faltered to the tune of 51-7 to Bonnies in the quarterfinals. Bonnies winning wasn’t the surprise, it was the manner of the winning.

It was only the second loss in 15s for Brown in the last four years, during which they have won two NCR titles.

“We had a ton of possession the first 20 minutes and every time we made a mistake, they capitalized on it. Credit to them for that,” Brown Head Coach David LaFlamme told GRR. “We just struggled to connect the dots on anything we attempted to do.”

Some dependable players had an off day and Brown had to make some lineup changes, too, but LaFlamme said St Bonaventure was the better side.

“In the end, I feel Bonnies would have edged us out had we played better, but the scoreline should have been less dramatic. I guess we were bound to underperform one game eventually... Unfortunately this was the one.”

For St. Bonaventure, they bring a strong kicking game led by Noah Edwards, Koen Webb, and Troy Herldt, and they add to that some powerful attacking talents such as Niku Otinero and Manu Taula. With a strong tight five they have good bones.

Bonnies plays a Walsh side that may not have won NCR’s D1, but what was essentially their program won it all as Notre Dame College two years ago. Yes there has been a lot of turnover but this Cavaliers team carries the same attitude—they don’t get discouraged; they shrug off setbacks; they play tough in the scrum and maul; they punish mistakes.

Steph Herbst plays hard in the midfield. Wing/fullback Ayabonga Mkhokeli is super fast and can attack from anywhere. GRR spoke with the Walsh players after their in-season loss to Belmont Abbey, and they were angry, not at each other, but at themselves. They will not be fun to play against.

Belmont Abbey is another team that doesn’t care about setbacks. Head Coach Genaro Fessia was working them through a specific way to play and it was a bit of a struggle. When you try to keep the ball alive, failure can mean five or seven points the other way.

It takes precision and teamwork and discipline. And it takes being strong in contact and … above all … patience.

Patience and discipline, and being powerful when you’re hit, started to put it together for the Crusaders. Their 40-11 loss to St. Bonaventure and a dicey 25-22 win over a struggling Kutztown, followed by a 47-19 loss to Queens, all painted a picture of a team that wasn’t quite there yet. And then they beat Walsh, and followed that up with a win over Wheeling. Yes Walsh beat them again in the placement game in the ARC, but the Crusaders put up over 40 on Thomas More and Notre Dame. 

The attack approach seemed to be connecting. 

Now they have to show how much they’ve improved against a Queens team that has been focusing on being together. Head Coach Tyree Reed consistently talks about playing as one, and especially on defense.

Reed has done a solid job making the changes since Frank McKinney moved on, but it’s not a massive coaching shift as Reed has been with the program for years. But there were some adjustments the team had to make and they made them on the fly nicely.

Still, September was a tough time as Queens lost to Navy in a non-conference match, were pipped by St. Bonaventure, and tied Wheeling on October 3. The lessons? Play to the final whistle. Too many teams have the ability to pour in tries if you clock off mentally, and that was a crucial thing for the players to learn. That led to Queens reversing those last two setbacks, beating SBU by four and then beating Wheeling 45-28.

Photo Galleries

Spotlight