It didn't. Cal played fast and started to test the BYU defense. That forced the Cougars to try to slow the onslaught and, of course, that often leads to penalties. Cal's forwards marched into the BYU 22 and the ball was sent wide for Max Clark on the edge for the go-ahead try. On the back foot BYU gave up a penalty after a kick to the wing by the Bears. Scrumhalf Solomon Williams tapped quickly and was over. Now it was 31-19.
Senior co-captain Nathan Zylstra, who had been out with injury since February, came off the bench at minute 50 and made an immediate impact. He carried a ball in from the back of a maul just three minutes later and was over, much to the delight of his teammates. Now with their tails up the Bears continued to play quickly. Another BYU penalty led to points as Schumacher put a kick over, thus making it a four-score game at 41-19.
It almost seemed like it had been just a few seconds, and yes BYU was now looking down the barrel of a 22-point deficit with only 16 minutes to go. Of course they tries to get there and tries Vaitohi got over for a key score that perhaps signaled a comeback at 41-26. Cal put any thoughts of a Cougar miracle aside, working their way into BYU territory, and as they were going wide and getting close to the tryline, Wyatt Parry was penalized for a no-wrap tackle. This close to the goal it turned out to be a costly penalty as Cal was awarded a penalty try and Parry was off for 10 minutes—most likely the rest of the game.
It was a tough call and a bang-bang play as Parry had gone for the ankles. Certainly it marked the end of any BYU comeback hopes. Cal was back to see Santos burst through from long range when BYU had been on the march. BYU added one more at the end, but the game was Cal's.
For BYU, this was the end of a pretty remarkable run and a step closer to the prominence they enjoyed in the 2000s and 2010s. All-in-all BYU ended the season 12-3, losing only to Life, Saint Mary's, and Cal. They scored an astonishing 851 points in those 15 games, good for 57 points per game. And more importantly, they seemed to have found their identity as a team that can score from almost anywhere.
For Cal, this has been an up-and-down year, but one in which they were able to garner revenge for a loss to Saint Mary's, then revenge for a loss to BYU. Now they face the only other team to beat them this season, Navy, May 6 in Houston in the D1A Championship Match.
Cal 55
Tries: Aguero, Santos 2, O'Connell, Clark, Williams, Zylstra, Pentaly Try
Convs: Schumacher 5, Penalty Try
Pens: Schumacher
BYU 31
Tries: Tenney 2, Vaitohi 2, Toso
Convs: Hammer 3
Scoring Timeline:
Cal vs. BYU
2:00 – Aguero 5, Schumacher 2
5:00 – Santos 5
14:00 – BYU 5, BYU 2
24:00 – BYU 5
30:00 – O’Connell 5, Schumacher 2
33:00 – BYU 5, BYU 2
Half: Cal 19, BYU 19
46:00 – Clark 5
49:00 – Williams 5, Schumacher 2
53:00 – Zylstra 5, Schumacher 2
64:00 – Schumacher 3
69:00 – BYU 5, BYU 2
73:00 – Cal 7 (Penalty Try)
78:00 – Santos 5, Schumacher 2
79:00 – BYU 5
Final: Cal 55, BYU 31
