Skip to main content
10.31.2026
Ohio State huddle 2026.
Arkansas State may have won the game, but Ohio State still made a statement.
Author: Alex Goff

In a result that was almost a massive upset, Arkansas State held on to beat Ohio State 44-42 in a game that was quite the barnburner.

While the Buckeyes have made huge strides this year with what is still a fairly young squad, they were not expected to beat ASU. in Jonesboro Of course, that's why they play the game.

ASU burst out of the gate and led early on. But as the game progressed, Ohio State adjusted well and closed the gap.

"We took a half to adjust to their physicality," said Ohio State Head Coach Peter Malcolm. He added that despite the loss, "I was really pleased with getting some Midwest table points out of the trip.

"Honestly we think we should have had that one."

Arkansas State opened the scoring with a driving maul, and kept the pressure up. Their forwards were halted a bit but the Red Wolves then took it in off a perfectly-weighted kick from scrumhalf Sange Mbuto and a well-timed catch from wing Paco Cisneros.

But Ohio State answered almost immediately with some quick hands down the line before fullback Tommy Kilbane drew his defender, passed to wing Jack Dulik, took the hit, and watched from the ground as Dulik scored in the corner.

And here is where there was a potential difference-maker. Kilbane is an excellent goalkicker and slotted the extras from the touchline to make it Arkansas State 10, Ohio State 7.

Still Arkansas State was ferocious in defense and with the ball, making sure the Ohio State players would remember being hit by them.

A surging run in traffic by captain and No. 8 Aaron van Dyk drew in the OSU defense and then a little shake-n-bake from fullback Ned Madden opened up a gap and he cruised through. Mbuto was good on the extras for a 17-7 Red Wolves lead.

Ohio State skipper caught Arkansas State napping with a quick tap and he went straight through to score under the posts to make it 17-14. Now Arkansas State knew they were in a fight, and opted for posts the next time they had a kickable penalty—Mbuto netted the three points and it was 20-14.

But Ohio State wouldn't go away. A promising Red Wolves attack down one side led to a wide kick from flyhalf Joshua Bands. But this time the Buckeyes nabbed it. Scrumhalf Mark French—what was he doing their?—caught the ball on the galloped and raced 70 meters untouched to dot it down under the sticks. Kick was good, and Ohio State led 21-20.

This is where Arkansas State showed their composure, marching down to the Ohio State 22 and methodically carrying it over.

The Red Wolves had chances after that. They were poached in the red zone and lost the ball forward at the tryline thanks to a desperate tackle by lock Owen Shultz. That play ended the first half.

Ohio State started the second half camped out in the ASU 22. Their forwards works hard to get it close, and the Red Wolves helped with some ill discipline. Finally USA U20 lock Jayden Williams powered through for the score. Once again Kilbane hit the extras and it was 28-25.

But Arkansas State's formula was still working—figurative punches in the middle, and shiftiness out wide. Again it was van Dyk getting the defense scrambling and Cisneros unleashing the sidestep to score.

Arkansas State now led 32-28.

But the Red Wolves' discipline hurt them again. Offside when they were defending well, and OSU took the lineout and mauled it. ASU held on, but after a run to the line by Kennedy, hooker Paddy McMahon was there for the pass from French and he blasted his way to the line.

Kilbane remained perfect on his kicked to make it Ohio State 35 Arkansas State 32.

But the alternating scoring finally ended. ASU was able to score twice in quick succession to grab a two-score lead at 44-35. The Red Wolves did well to close it out, playing much of the remaining minutes in the Ohio State end of the field. 

The game ended with Ohio State scoring a rather astonishing try down the left sideline in which it looked like ASU had it all stopped when an offload landed in Sam Bosco's hand. Another USA age-grade player, Bosco took off at an angle. Finally, inevitably, he was caught but as he was taken down there was Kilbane to get the offload and score.

The fullback converted to make it 44-42 and that was the final play of the game.

This was a game in which Ohio State garnered a ton of respect from a hard and experienced Arkansas State team. The lead changed seven times. Arkansas State scored seven tries and converted three; Ohio State scored six and converted all of them.

For Ohio State, Schultz, French, Williams, and Kilbane were all outstanding. The center pairing of Kennedy and Gavin Krock was strong throughout. For Arkansas State, they rely on van Dyk perhaps too much, but he can carry the load. Mbuto was snappy and the outside backs, especially Ollie Pye and Cisneros, were consistently dangerous. 

But despite the loss, it's Ohio State people are talking about. 

Photo Galleries

Spotlight